Friday, November 20, 2026

Moving to Maui: When BAFO Doesn’t Mean Final?

We made our Best and Final Offer yesterday, including a provision for the seller to pay a portion of our closing costs, and otherwise matching their previous counter-offer. We were quite surprised to receive yet another counter-offer, when we clearly gave them a take-it-or-leave-it offer. They accepted all of our terms, except for the closing costs provision.

I talked with my wife about this; I favor rejecting their counter and resubmitting our BAFO, to stay open until later today. If the seller does not accept, then there’s no deal. Our “final offer” has to mean something. During this whole process, my wife is the one who has been evaluating the deal at every turn and she has been pushing hard for better terms, firmly believing that the house was overpriced. The tables turned at this stage: she was ready to give up on the closing costs, I said that we have to stand behind our final offer.

We talked with our agent about this plan, emphasized our intent to end this process today, and agreed to extend one final offer with the exact same terms as our previous final offer.

I also made it clear that, while I still want a deal, I’m pessimistic. I told her that I’m already thinking about how to proceed, asking her to continue sending us new listings and we will restart our active search early next year. I said this, because it’s true, but also because I wanted her to internalize the situation: we really are ready to walk away from this deal. If she knows that, she will interact with the seller’s agent accordingly.

Hours later…

Well it took them most of the day to respond. But eventually they took the deal.

Now we’re under contract to complete a lot of stuff, hopefully getting the keys to the place in mid-December. In the meantime, we are continuing to clear our house out for sale. I’ve made several trips to Goodwill, one trip to the dump, and more are looming. Every week our dumpster is full on collection day. I’m trimming bushes now while the weather is still good. And I’m selling stuff on Facebook Marketplace. We have an appointment to consign some furniture for sale. I have an enormous pile of books to get rid of: they’re too heavy to ship. It kills me that I’ll probably end up taking them to the dump. And we have a reservation for a trailer to take some large items to my wife’s family’s vacation property in Maine. We have to do this one next week - the road will be impassable with snow if we wait much longer.

After all that back-and-forth with the seller, the deal is done. We’re moving to Maui!

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Moving to Maui: What a Confusing Sequence of Events

The listing agent responded to our latest offer by asserting that the comparables in the neighborhood supported a higher price per square foot and higher total price. We said, “Show us.” Only then did it dawn on me that she was using a different number for total square feet.

The listing says 2,060 square feet in larger font right at the top. Buried in the text description it uses 2,172. We’ve been using 2060 all along because that’s the obvious number right at the top. The listing agent has been using 2172. The difference is a permitted addition that is not included in the county’s tax records. 2060 is what the banks will use when assessing whether to lend, 2172 is what the listing agent wants to use because of course that’s her justification for a higher price.

We find this to be confusing at best, and a misleading bait and switch at worst.

If we buy this house, we’re going to be stuck with 2060 when/if we sell it. We’re not eager to pay a premium, only to have the actual value immediately be significantly lower. And there’s still the matter of the unclosed permit and the fire code violations. We’ve made our best-and-final-offer (BAFO), and we’ll see what happens. We’re prepared to walk away at this point. It would actually be helpful to us if we end this now because we can stay in our house and will have a longer runway to get it ready for sale. Then we can restart our search in January 2027.

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Moving to Maui: Offer/Counteroffer Ping Pong

After we made our initial purchase offer yesterday, the seller turned it around much more quickly than I expected. They made a counter offer with enough reduction to show they’re serious, but still asking for a premium price. Their agent also wants to change the survey requirement, proposing a less-stringent “staking” to mark the property line. Our agent recommended staying with the survey requirement because the seller had done a lot of work building retaining walls; we want to be sure we know where the lines are and whether there’s any encroachment. This completes round 1.

So we made a counter offer, starting round 2. We started with the difference between our offer and their counter offer, multiplied by 40%, and increased our offer by that amount, and retained the survey requirement. We’re hoping they counter again, narrowing the gap enough that they either accept or we go to round 3 with a much smaller difference between us. We’re reluctant to go to round 4.

Oh, and we got rid of more stuff in the house.

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Moving to Maui: More Financing Hell and Clearing 30 Years of Clutter

After much back and forth with three different financial institutions, we were finally ready to make an offer on the house that we like.

We revisited our initial research and realized that we never got resolution on two issues: an outstanding fire code violation from many years ago (something about brush on the property) and an open electrical permit. We’ve seen the property - there’s a lot of green shrubbery, no dry brush. The electrical permit is probably just an oversight. We had another back and forth interaction with our sales agent and she brought it to the seller’s attention, and the seller’s agent is now attempting to resolve those issues.

We can still back out, but we finalized our initial offer and I signed this morning.

In the meantime, we’ve been in our house for 30+ years. We raised our children here. We’ve known for a long time that we needed to start clearing out, but never made it a high priority. Now it’s a high priority.

I’ve been selling, donating, and just plain putting stuff on the street for people to take. Our dumpster is full and we already have stuff staged to fill it again after the next trash pickup. I’m using up the consumables for the yard, seed, limestone, fertilizer… It’s Autumn, as I use tools for the last time I’m putting them out for sale or free. I got rid of fans, a fertilizer spreader, a sprinkler, a ladder. We took tons of (mostly) cold weather clothing to Goodwill. We won’t need (much) warm clothing on Maui, but will occasionally travel, sometimes to cool places.

We went to a bulk paper shredding place this morning. We had piles of paper left over from the time when paper was the way to keep records. We had an entire filing cabinet to clear. Now it’s empty and about to get listed for sale.

I listed several items on Craigslist and Facebook Marketplace. It seems Craigslist is the place to get rid of stuff if just giving it away, while Facebook is the place to sell things. I’m avoiding EBay (for now) because I really don’t want to get into the shipping process.

Saturday, November 14, 2026

Moving to Maui: Clearing the House

I thought I’d have another full year to do this…

My wife and I had talked about moving to Hawaii, and looking at the events we have planned, it seemed impossible that it would happen before October 2027. Little did I know we would find and sign a contract on a house in October 2026. We’ve been in our existing house for 30+ years. We have 30+ years of clutter and accumulated stuff. Now we’re trying to do in 2+ months what I had planned to take 12 months to do.

I’m now in a sprint to gather things and take them to Goodwill, and to list things on Facebook Marketplace, and to interact with buyers. We’re also dealing with the bank and real estate agents and home inspectors. Soon we’ll have to deal with people to do some deferred repairs on our house. And while my wife’s foot is still healing, I have to be her chauffeur, sometimes into DC, other times around the local area, sometimes to medical appointments.

Next week we are taking a U-Haul trailer full of stuff to her family vacation home in Maine. That’s going to eat a few days. I knew this was going to be a surge effort; it’s turning into day-upon-day of go-go-go to get stuff out and get stuff done.

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Moving to Maui: Financing Hell

We asked a lot of questions about the house that we want and fortunately there are no show stoppers. Now we’re working on financing.

You would think this is doable: we have no mortgage, intend to sell our current house, and have 4 times the cost of the new house in investments. But because I’m retired, the finance person is balking. We’re jumping through hoops to show steady income, where I’m now taking regular IRA distributions that we don’t need. But, we’ll sit on the cash until things settle down.

So now we’re on the verge of getting a couple of pre-approval letters. In the next few days, we’re making an offer to buy the house.

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Moving to Maui: A Tale of Two Houses

It’s a few days after I wrote my last post. We asked lots of questions about our preferred house. We didn’t like the answers.

There’s an unpermitted lanai, unclosed permits for prior work, the fence is over the line into public land, most of the things in the house won’t convey, the solar panels and batteries are leased with no specifics about the terms (other than the monthly fee), there’s a water leak, and it’s still overpriced. No single item is a show-stopper; taken altogether, we’ve decided to eliminate this house as a candidate.

We also liked another house and had kept that one in mind as an alternative. The location isn’t as good, and it’s not as well suited to our planned lifestyle, but it’s a better financial deal, is larger, has owned (not leased) solar, is in great shape, and has a fantastic view of the ocean and nearby Molokai. There’s no lawn. That sounds wonderful after 30+ years of mowing and raking. Everything in and around the house was done with an eye to low-maintenance. Now we’re researching this property to see if we want to make an offer.