We made our Best and Final Offer yesterday, including a provision for the seller to pay a portion of our closing costs, and otherwise matching their previous counter-offer. We were quite surprised to receive yet another counter-offer, when we clearly gave them a take-it-or-leave-it offer. They accepted all of our terms, except for the closing costs provision.
I talked with my wife about this; I favor rejecting their counter and resubmitting our BAFO, to stay open until later today. If the seller does not accept, then there’s no deal. Our “final offer” has to mean something. During this whole process, my wife is the one who has been evaluating the deal at every turn and she has been pushing hard for better terms, firmly believing that the house was overpriced. The tables turned at this stage: she was ready to give up on the closing costs, I said that we have to stand behind our final offer.
We talked with our agent about this plan, emphasized our intent to end this process today, and agreed to extend one final offer with the exact same terms as our previous final offer.
I also made it clear that, while I still want a deal, I’m pessimistic. I told her that I’m already thinking about how to proceed, asking her to continue sending us new listings and we will restart our active search early next year. I said this, because it’s true, but also because I wanted her to internalize the situation: we really are ready to walk away from this deal. If she knows that, she will interact with the seller’s agent accordingly.
Hours later…
Well it took them most of the day to respond. But eventually they took the deal.
Now we’re under contract to complete a lot of stuff, hopefully getting the keys to the place in mid-December. In the meantime, we are continuing to clear our house out for sale. I’ve made several trips to Goodwill, one trip to the dump, and more are looming. Every week our dumpster is full on collection day. I’m trimming bushes now while the weather is still good. And I’m selling stuff on Facebook Marketplace. We have an appointment to consign some furniture for sale. I have an enormous pile of books to get rid of: they’re too heavy to ship. It kills me that I’ll probably end up taking them to the dump. And we have a reservation for a trailer to take some large items to my wife’s family’s vacation property in Maine. We have to do this one next week - the road will be impassable with snow if we wait much longer.
After all that back-and-forth with the seller, the deal is done. We’re moving to Maui!