Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Moving to Maui: Offer/Counteroffer Ping Pong

After we made our initial purchase offer yesterday, the seller turned it around much more quickly than I expected. They made a counter offer with enough reduction to show they’re serious, but still asking for a premium price. Their agent also wants to change the survey requirement, proposing a less-stringent “staking” to mark the property line. Our agent recommended staying with the survey requirement because the seller had done a lot of work building retaining walls; we want to be sure we know where the lines are and whether there’s any encroachment. This completes round 1.

So we made a counter offer, starting round 2. We started with the difference between our offer and their counter offer, multiplied by 40%, and increased our offer by that amount, and retained the survey requirement. We’re hoping they counter again, narrowing the gap enough that they either accept or we go to round 3 with a much smaller difference between us. We’re reluctant to go to round 4.

Oh, and we got rid of more stuff in the house.

No comments: